AP – Madison, Wisconsin Brown County Taxpayers Association and a conservative Wisconsin law firm have filed a lawsuit to halt federal student loan forgiveness.
In a complaint filed in federal court on Tuesday, the Wisconsin Institute for Law and Liberty (WILL) claimed that President Joe Biden’s loan forgiveness programme was unfair and amounted to taxation without representation. It requests that a judge immediately block student debt forgiveness while the lawsuit is being resolved.
According to the lawsuit, Biden wrongfully avoided Congress in order to implement his proposal and lacked the authority to forgive student loans.
In the lawsuit filed in the U.S. Federal District Court for the Eastern District of Wisconsin, WILL is representing the Brown County Taxpayers Association.
The taxpayers association contends that the scheme violates the equal protection clause of the Fifth Amendment because it is partially intended to assist Black borrowers and explicitly states that its goal is to create “racial fairness.”
In a statement, Rich Heidel, president of the Brown County Taxpayers Association, said that student loan debt relief “takes from one set of people and unfairly distributes the spoils to another group.
The idea is nothing more than a modernised version of King George III’s Stamp Act, which involved heavy taxation and spending without the involvement of the representatives of the people.
The plan’s addition of hundreds of billions to the deficit is another reason why the taxpayers group considers it “exceedingly foolish.”
About 1 in 5 Americans, according to the Office of Financial Aid, have student loans. The Education Data Initiative estimates that in 2020, there will be an average student debt balance of $30,000.
Under Biden’s plan, borrowers with household incomes under $250,000 or those earning less than $125,000 would have $10,000 in student loan debt cancelled. Receivers of Pell Grants, who often exhibit greater financial need, would also receive a $10,000 debt forgiveness bonus. Of those, up to one-third would have their debts waived off. The remaining two-thirds would still owe money on their loans.
According to the White House, the plan would help more than 685,000 people in Wisconsin.
In Wisconsin, the amount of the debt that was forgiven might be taxed. The next state budget will include a repair from the Democratic administration of Gov. Tony Evers, but the Republican-controlled Legislature will need to adopt it. For Evers to formally make that request, he must win reelection in November.
Brown County taxpayers and a Wisconsin law firm file a lawsuit to prevent student loan forgiveness.
About Author
